Growing up it was always Ellen and Joan, the names, their stories seemed inseparable.
Joan and Ellen were
a partnership forged permanently when they lived with our grandmother
in St. Louis during World War II. Joan was born in March, 1942, 18 months after Ellen. It’s a tribute
to Ellen’s generous nature that they weren’t competitive. Ellen
was the senior partner but by the time I came along 4 years later
Joan and Ellen were a given. They might have had their disagreements
but it stayed between them. Ellen more than anyone else appreciated
Joan.
Ellen was the star
of the show, the strong character, the tom boy who could hold her own
with the boys and shoot marbles better than any of us. At eight or
nine years old Ellen wanted the full Hopalong Cassidy outfit and when
she got it, wore it with pride. Joan was the background. I don’t
remember much about her at all and in those days I think that was as
much Joan as it was Ellen, Joan was in the shadow. Joan was a person
of strong character and intensity, but she kept it to herself.
After the Barracks,
the second bedroom was always theirs. At our new home on Magnolia
Boulevard Ellen and Joan’s room was this pristine sacred space,
with twin beds, bedspreads, curtains, a book case and a desk. The
most precious object in the room was a turquoise Motorola Clock Radio
which Ellen kept tuned to KFAC, the classical music station in LA.
Today when I hear Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concerto #1 I’m transported
back to the sound coming from Joan and Ellen’s bedroom, The Gas
Hour theme.
In school Ellen was
everyone’s favorite. In the 8th grade Ellen was the
captain of the Bellarmine Jefferson Guards, Monsignor Keating’s
doctrinaire and whimsical fusion of devotion and patriotism into a
kind of World War I home guard. She and the boy captain led Flag
Salute our morning formation, where at attention we recited prayers
composed for the occasion and sang the national anthem while raising
the flag. We sang Hail Columbia. Monsignor didn’t like that new
fangled Star Spangled Banner.
I think by the time
Joan started high school she had had enough of always being Ellen’s
sister at school. She began to shine as her own star. We Duggans
were a bright bunch but Joan was undoubtedly the smartest of us all.
She played the clarinet in band, she roller skated at Harry’s
Roller Rink, and she became the science teacher's pet, Sister Mary Paul
Anthony (Catherine O’Dwyer).. The rest of the world was
terrified of Paul Anthony but Joan flourished under her guidance.
In 1959 Ellen left
for the nunnery. Joan got her own room and was on her own at
Bellarmine Jefferson, winning awards and honors and a full
scholarship to Clarke College in Dubuque Iowa. Dubuque was the
mother house of the nuns at St. Roberts and Clarke is their college.
In those days I filled in as Joan’s ally. Her little brother to
Harry’s Roller Rink. She was very pretty. Ellen never had much
interest in boys, but the boys noticed Joan and she liked the
attention.
Before she started
the college sent Joan a reading list of books they thought she should
be reading. She shared it with me. I devoured it and let Joan know
the ones I thought she should read. Joan was excited about chemistry
and I wondered what it was all about so I read a chapter of one of
her books. The chapter was Boyle’s law and when I took the
entrance exam for high school, the science section was a paragraph on
Boyle’s Law and questions on the reading. I was by that
coincidence one of the smartest students to enter St. Francis High
School that year Later I was a big disappointment to the science
teacher.
Joan came home for
the summers. She was a young woman, smoking, drinking beer and quite
sophisticated. She got a summer job as an information operator at
The Telephone Company. I was always struck by the fact that she was a
Chemistry major with a Latin minor. Joan had learned to drive on an
automatic transmission. The summer I was chafing to get my driver’s
license having learned to drive in a few lessons earlier in the year.
Joan was looking for a car and realized it would be good to know how
to drive a stick shift. I had mastered the basics of driving on our
1948 Studebaker, our second car, our mother’s junker.
She asked me to
teach her. Our exchange was after our lesson I could drive the car
with her as my over 18 licensed driver. That exchange was a strong
element of our growing bond. We had fun together. One time I was
walking her through the sequence of making a left turn: slowing,
clutching, downshifting. Just then I looked and we were headed directly for the house on the corner, “And steer! And Steer!” I
shouted. We both had a good laugh and I had a story to tell.
I
think at the beginning of grad school Joan
bought an American Rambler. It was not cool
or stylish but it was a good
little car and had a stick shift. It was practical like Joan. It
suited her. I don’t remember all the cars Joan had but they
included a big Ford Bronco or Explorer and a big Ford pickup truck,
macho cars. It was fun to
watch her grip the steering wheel and use the step to
climb into them.
Joan was short 5 feet or 5 foot 1 but she liked the cars and she
played Country and Western music on the radio sometimes. It tickled
her sense of irony. Joan wasn’t macho but she was tough.
I began drinking
beer at home when I was 16 and stopped hiding that I smoked. So when
Joan came home in the summer before she graduated we drank beer
together. That was another one of our bonds. I contributed and she
bought and we’d bring it home and share with Pop including whatever
he had at home. The three of us would drink together, we drank
whatever was there and finished it off. These were convivial days
and very social. For me and probably Joan too they were the first
time that our father relaxed and talked to us. He was coming out of
his PTSD shell that had lasted for over 20 years. We reveled in his
conviviality.
When I started
college, Joan generously offered to share an apartment with me and we
lived in a furnished one bedroom apartment on Sepulveda Boulevard
near Venice Boulevard in National City. I slept on the living room
couch. I didn’t see much of Joan. She was studying Organic Chemistry and played bridge. I was busy going to college on my own.
When our paths crossed we both enjoyed Swansons Frozen Pot Pies. We
did quite well together. We were good roommates. I have always been
grateful for Joan’s generosity.
The next year she
got an apartment near Culver City and I went on campus to the dorms.
And then I met Cathy
and joined the Air Force and Joan finished her Masters at UCLA and
went on to begin teaching at East Los Angeles College. I was in the Air Force, got married, and then went to
England. Cathy and my first summer in Bedford Joan came to visit. I
think it was her first time in Europe and before she came to Bedford
she went to a language program in Spain. I remember we had another a
coworker to dinner at our flat when Joan was there. I can’t
remember his name, a little older than me. He commended Joan on
being in college and that she should stay in school and work hard in
chemistry. He deflated when she said she wasn’t a student in
college, but a professor. Joan was very pretty but looked very young,
not like most chemistry professors.
That summer Joan had
met this guy in Spain and apparently they were quite taken with
each other. Somehow we got the word that this guy Michael was
desperate to call her and she was desperate to get the call. Using
the phone in England in those days meant going to the red Call Box a
block and a half away. Joan and Michael seem to take it personally that we didn't have a phone. They
managed somehow to reach each other.
When Cathy and I
returned to California in 1971, Joan and Michael were trying to
maintain a long distance relationship between Monterey Park and the
Bronx. Joan converted to Judaism and had a ceremony welcoming her to
the tribe at a synagogue in Glendale. My parents and Ellen were
there. We were all happy that Joan was happy, happy to be Jewish,
and she had found her true love. Someone asked me how was it my
sister converted to Judaism. I told them when you grow up Irish
Catholic, it’s easy to convert to something else; Joan found an
intellectual and spiritual home in Judaism.
She took a
sabbatical and went to live with Michael in New York. She went to
Hunter College for a year. And Joan and Michael got married in
Connecticut, and paid my way to the wedding, I was still an undergrad
at UCLA. It was a wonderful wedding with chuppa and Michael breaking
the glass. It was at a cousin’s of Michael in Connecticut.
Michael was very proud of the food, Middle Eastern, Sephardic, humus,
pita bread and Michael’s favorite, baba ganoush. The caterer was
Lebanese. Joan and Michael stayed in New York.
As agreed they came
out to California the following year, just for Michael to try it.
Michael didn’t seem very impressed by California and he didn’t
think they would stay. I remember his conversion occurred with an
Orange Tree he bought. When it first bloomed and had fruit during
the winter. Michael became a Californian.
Cathy and I and Joan
and Michael were friends, we prepared and ate dinners with wine
together and cocktails or brandy afterwards. We were their guests
for the Chanukah and Passover holidays. One day with satisfaction I
realized my boys didn’t think of the holidays as exotic, just
something we celebrated with Joan and Michael. They knew to set a
place for Elijah, to ask the question and in December to look for
Chanukah gelt.
In 1977 we went down
to Brotman Hospital in Culver City to be part of their new baby’s
birth. Being Joan and Michael I don’t think we saw the baby that
day, she was born. Shortly thereafter we got to see Laurie Reyna
Pessah. That was a big event. Laurie was Joan and Michael’s
special child and very special she was. She was beautiful,
talented, very smart and charming from the start and so she is today.
She is Joan and Michael’s child and the best of both of them.
Cathy and I
struggled in our marriage, there were good times and bad times and
1983 was a bad time. Cathy and I separated. I readily accepted the
role of the bad guy and Cathy was the aggrieved party. She made sure
all of my family knew my transgressions. It seemed Joan and Michael
sided with Cathy and I was left out.
Eventually I was
partially reinstated. At that same time I got sober and that became
another barrier between Joan and me
Everyone
in the family was pretty surprised. Cathy, now Kate, immediately
joined Alanon and became a 12 Step Master though gratefully she
didn’t have anything to do with me at the time. Her insights may
not have been helpful to me at the time. Joan and Michael noticed it
and were very interested. By this time, a lot of people knew Joan
drank too much, including Joan. Not long after, I think it might
have been the that summer when people began to realize not only had I
stopped drinking but I was sober and getting more so every day.
One day
Michael called and we had to meet downtown to “discuss” Joan’s
drinking. Michael was very concerned that we should get Joan sober,
she really needed to stop drinking. Around then I gave my copy of
Alcohol Anonymous to Joan or for Joan. Of course, Joan and I never
talked about alcoholism. It’s makes sense if you’re Irish. I was
sober, she knew it and she knew she needed to stop drinking too. She
had The Book and I think she had looked at it. Michael gave me
updates on how Joan was doing. I learned Joan had tried AA but it
wasn’t for her, too religious.
For
Joan the Protestant sounding rhetoric of the Big Book was a deal
breaker. She’d do it on her own. I was struck by the rhetoric, an
artifact from the 1930s but it never bothered me. I was an atheist
and just let it go. Particularly in California AA is strong on a
Higher Power or “god as you understand him or her,” a big
sidestep of the God thing for most of us. It is about surrender,
admitting that we can’t do it on our own, that we have to give up
trying to control it. Joan couldn’t do that. She tried.
Alcoholism isn’t a lack of will power or character. Functional
alcoholics are people of incredible character and strong will.
Trudging
on, getting up, doing what has to be done instead of giving up,
instead of letting go, takes courage and is an act of incredible
will. Joan was a strong willed person. She did not give up. She
tried and she tried. Joan fought her alcoholism up to the end I
imagine.
She was
uncomfortable with my sobriety. When I visited she wouldn’t have
anything to drink and that was hard. I’d stay for an hour or two.
She shared her garden and water course. She showed me her book
binding projects.
We were
cordial but we were never close again. As we aged Joan had some
health problems. We didn’t talk about it but I was very proud of
my sister for being a leader and guide for people learning to live
with colostomy bags. And then she began to suffer from dementia, I
didn’t see that. Michael had problems seeing and driving, so they
were a driving team, Michael navigated and Joan drove.
And
then Joan passed away. I would have liked to have been a lot closer
and there for Joan but it didn’t happen. And she died September
2016. And I miss her.
My
daughter Paloma was in the first grade when Joan died. And then
Paloma was having problems in school. We looked into it and she was
grieving for Joan. We hadn’t thought much about it. We didn’t
think Joan’s passing had been important in Paloma’s six year old
world. I didn’t realize that Paloma and Joan had bonded. It
happened one afternoon when Joan took Paloma aside and showed her all
of her bookbinding work, the tools and what she did with them. I
felt very bad for Paloma but it also made me feel very grateful that
Paloma had experienced my beloved sister Joan and that she loved her,
just like I did.